Palavras-chave:
HIPPOPOTAMUS HUNT, PREDYNASTIC, ARCHAEOZOOLOGY, SYMBOLISM, ICONOGRAPHY, CROSS-LINED WAREResumo
Hippopotamus hunting as an iconographical motif is widely attested during most of Egyptian history. Both private and royal Egyptian tombs spanning from early Old Kingdom to Roman times show these images in their walls. The motif was often depicted in Predynastic iconography but, due to some of its particularities, some authors suggested that hippopotami were, in fact, not killed but rather captured alive. Decades have passed, and evidence both ar- chaeological and archaeozoological has since grown significantly. We now have enough sources to reassess the corpus of evidence to debunk or ratify such hypotheses. Particularly relevant to confirm these was the finding at Hierakonpolis of a young hippopotamus’ remains showing signs of having been kept captive in the village. Moreover, it is helpful to examine evidence not taken into account by the authors such as ethnohistorical research and the latest archaeozoological find- ings. The outcome of this research seems to suggest that the killing of hippopotami did, in fact, take place during hunting expeditions, due to the danger of transporting the beasts alive. Further- more, the idea of iconographic evidence as a narrative of actual events should be challenged and understood instead as being one of symbolic nature.
Downloads
Referências
ABD EL KAREM, M. 2013: Die Nutzung tierischer Ressourcen während des 5. und 4. Jahrtausends v. Chr. in Ägypten. Unpublished Master's Thesis. Universität Wien.
ADAMS, B. 1995: Ancient Nekhen: Garstang in the city of Hierakonpolis. Egypt Studies Association Publication, n° 3. SIA Publishing.
ADLER, A. 2007: La guerra y el Estado primitivo. In: Abensour, M. (comp.): El espíritu de las leyes salvajes. Una nueva antropología política: 163-188. Del Sol, Buenos Aires.
ALTENMÜLLER, H. 1980: Jagdritual. In: Helck, W. & Westendorf, W. (eds.): Lexikon der Ägyptologie, Band III: 231-233. Otto Harrasowitz, Wiesbaden.
AYRTON, E.R. & LOAT, W.L.S. 1911: The Pre-Dynastic Cemetery at El Mahasna. MEEF 31, London.
BARD, K. 1988: A Quantitative Analysis of the Predynastic Burials in Armant Cemetery 1400-1500. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 74: 39-55. https://doi.org/10.1177/030751338807400105
BEHRMANN, A. 1996: Das Nilpferd in der Vorstellungswelt der Alten Ägypter. Teil II, Textband. Reihe XXXVIII, Archäologie, Vol. 62. Europäische Hochschulschriften, Frankfurt.
BLACKMAN, A.M. & FAIRMAN, H.W. 1944: The Myth of Horus at Edfu III. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 30: 5-22. https://doi.org/10.1177/030751334403000103
BRÉMONT, A. 2018: Des éléphants, des hippopotames et des mouflons. Trois hypothèses de marqueurs animaux d'identités regionales pendant les periodes de Naqada I-II. Archéo-Nil 28: 69-98.
BRUNTON, G. 1937: Mostagedda and the Tasian Culture: British Museum Expedition to Middle Egypt, First and Second Years, 1928, 1929, London.
BRUNTON, G. & CATON-THOMPSON, G. 1928: The Badarian Civilization. BSAE & ERA 46, London.
CAMPAGNO, M. 2011: Kinship, concentration of population and the emergence of the State in the Nile Valley. In: Friedman, R.F. & Fiske, P.N. (eds.): Egypt at its Origins 3. Proceedings of the International Conference "Origin of the State. Predynastic and Early Dynastic Egypt". London, 27th July - 1st August 2008: 1229-1242. Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta 205. Peeters, Leuven.
CAMPAGNO, M. 2016: Surgimiento de lo estatal y liderazgo local en el valle del Nilo (IV-III milenios a.C.). In: Campagno, M.; Gallego, J. & García MacGaw, C. (comps.): Regímenes Políticos en el Mediterráneo Antiguo. Estudios del Mediterráneo Antiguo: 15-30. PEFSCEA N° 11. Miño y Dávila, Buenos Aires.
CULWICK, A.T. 1932: Hippo hunting amongst the Wandamba of Tanganyika Territory. Man 32: 276-278. https://doi.org/10.2307/2789804
DARNELL, J.C. 2009: Iconographic Attraction, Iconographic Syntax, and Tableaux of Royal Ritual Power in the Preand Proto-Dynastic Rock Inscriptions of the Theban West Desert. Archéo-Nil 19: 83-107.
DE MORGAN, J. 1896: Recherches sur les Origines de l'Egypte. 1: L'Age de la Pierre et des Métaux. 2: Ethnographie Préhistorique et Tombeau Royal de Naqada. Paris. https://doi.org/10.3406/bmsap.1896.5634
DIEGO ESPINEL, A. 2015: Angry hippos and resurrecting butterflies. Two Ancient Egyptian ethological observations?. In: Massiera, M.; Mathieu, B. & Rouffet, F. (eds.): Apprivoiser le sauvage / Taming the Wild: 119-128. Cahiers de l'ENiM 11, Université Paul Valéry Montpellier 3 CNRS.
DREYER, G. et al. 1998: Umm el-Qaab, Nachuntersuchungen im frühzeitlichen Königsfriedhof, 9./10. Vorbericht. Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts Abteilung Kairo 54: 77-167.
DREYER, G. et al. 2003: Umm el-Qaab, Nachuntersuchungen im frühzeitlichen Königsfriedhof, 13./14./15. Vorbericht. Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts Abteilung Kairo 65: 43-129.
EVANS, L. 2010: Animal Behavior in Egyptian Art. Representations of the Natural World in Memphite Tomb Scenes. Aris & Phillips, Oxford.
FLORES, D.V. 2004: Funerary sacrifice of animals in the Egyptian Predynastic period. In: Hendrickx, S.; Friedman, R.; Cialowicz, K. & Chlodnicki, M. (eds.): Egypt at its Origins. Studies in memory of Barbara Adams. Proceedings of the International Conference 'Origin of the State. Predynastic and Early Dynastic Egypt', Krakow, 28th August - 1st September 2002: 731-763. Leuven.
FRIEDMAN, R.F. 2004: Elephants at Hierakonpolis. In: Hendrickx, S.; Friedman, R.; Cialowicz, K. & Chlodnicki, M. (eds.): Egypt at its Origins. Studies in memory of Barbara Adams. Proceedings of the International Conference 'Origin of the State. Predynastic and Early Dynastic Egypt', Krakow, 28th August - 1st September 2002: 131-168. Leuven.
FRIEDMAN, R.F. et. al. 1999: Preliminary Report on Field Work at Hierakonpolis: 1996-1998. Journal of the American Research Center in Egypt 36: 1-35. https://doi.org/10.2307/40000200
FRIEDMAN, R.F. et. al. 2011: The elite predynastic cemetery at Hierakonpolis: 2009-2010 update. In: Friedman, R.F. & Fiske P.N. (eds.): Egypt at its Origins 3. Proceedings of the International Conference "Origin of the State. Predynastic and Early Dynastic Egypt". London, 27th July- 1st August 2008: 157-191. Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta 205. Peeters, Leuven.
GANDONNIÈRE, C. 2014: Chasseurs et équipes de chasseurs de l'Ancien au Nouvel Empire. Nehet 1: 47-69.
GAYUBAS, A. 2006: Guerra, parentesco y cambio social en las sociedades sin Estado del valle del Nilo prehistórico. In: Campagno, M. (coord.): Estudios sobre parentesco y Estado en el antiguo Egipto: 51-74. Del Signo, Buenos Aires.
GAYUBAS, A. 2016: Guerra, territorio y cambio social en el valle del Nilo preestatal. In: Campagno, M.; Gallego, J. & García MacGaw, C. (comps.): Regímenes Políticos en el Mediterráneo Antiguo. Estudios del Mediterráneo Antiguo: 31-44. PEFSCEA N° 11. Miño y Dávila, Buenos Aires.
GERMOND, Ph. & LIVET, J. 2001: Bestiaire Égyptien. Citadelles & Mazenod, Paris.
GRAFF, G. 2009: Les peintures sur vases de Naqada I - Naqada II. Nouvelle aproche sémiologique de l'iconographie prédynastique. Leuven University Press, Leuven. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt9qdz5x
GRAFF, G.; EYCKERMAN, M. & HENDRICKX, S. 2011: Architectural elements in decorated pottery and the ritual presentation of desert animals. In: Friedman, R.F & Fiske, R.N. (eds.): Egypt at its origins 3. Proceedings third international colloquium "Origin of the State. Predynastic and Early Dynastic Egypt": 437-465. Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta 205. Peeters, Leuven.
GREGORIUS, P. 1964: Die Wandamba (Tanganyika): Ein Forschungsbericht. Anthropos 59(1/2): 165-217.
GRISWOLD, W.A. 1992: Measuring Social Inequality at Armant. In: Adams, B. & Friedman, R.F. (eds.): The Followers of Horus. Studies dedicated to Michael Allen Hoffman 1944-1990: 193-198. ESA 2. Oxbow Monograph 20, Oxford.
HARTMANN, R. 2003: Keramik. In: Dreyer, G. et. al. (eds.): Umm el-Qaab. Nachuntersuchungen im frühzeitlichen Königsfriedhof 13./14./15. Vorbericht. Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts Abteilung Kairo 59: 80-85.
HARTMANN, R. 2008: Zwei Fragmente der White Cross.lined Ware aus dem Friedhof U in Abydos zu Gefässen aus dem Ägyptischen Museum Kairo. In: Engel, E-M.; Müller,
V. & Hartung, U. (eds.): Zeichen aus dem Sand. Streiflichter aus Ägyptens Geschichte zu Ehren von Günther Dreyer: 163-182. Menes 5. Otto-Harrasowitz, Wiesbaden.
HARTUNG, U. 2010: Hippopotamus hunters and bureaucrats: Elite Burials at Cemetery U at Abydos. In: Raffaele, F. et al. (eds.): Recent Discoveries and Latest Researches in Egyptology: Proceedings of the First Neapolitan Congress of Egyptology, Naples, June 18th - 20th, 2008: 107-120. Otto Harrassowitz, Wiesbaden.
HARTUNG, U.; ENGEL, E-M. & HARTMANN, R. 2012: Tell el-Fara'in - Buto 11. Vorbericht. Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts Abteilung Kairo 68: 83-114.
HENDRICKX, S. 2006: The dog, the Lycaon pictus and order over chaos. In: Kroeper, K.; Chlodnicki, M. & Kobusiewicz, M. (eds.): Archaeology of Early Northeastern Africa. In Memory of Lech Krzy?aniak: 723749. Studies in African Archaeology 9, Poznan.
HENDRICKX, S. 2011: L'Iconographie de la chasse dans le contexte social prédynastique. Archéo-Nil 20: 108-136.
HENDRICKX, S. 2013: Hunting and social complexity in Predynastic Egypt. Academie Royale des Sciences d'Outre-mer, Bulletin des Séances / Koninklijke Academie voor Overzeese Wetenschappen, Mededelingen der Zittingen 57(2-4): 237-263.
HENDRICKX, S. & EYCKERMAN, M. 2015: Les animaux savages dans l'Égypte prédynastique. In: Massiera, M.; Mathieu, B. & Rouffet, F. (eds.): Apprivoiser le sauvage/Taming the Wild: 197-210. Cahiers de l'ENiM 11, Université Paul Valéry Montpellier 3 CNRS.
HENDRICKX, S. et al. 2009: Late Predynastic/Early Dynastic rock art scenes of Barbary sheep hunting in Egypt's Western Desert. From capturing wild animals to the women of the 'Acacia House'. In: Riemer, H.; Förster, F.; Herb, M. & Pöllath, N. (eds.): Desert animals in the eastern Sahara: Status, economic significance and cultural reflection in antiquity. Proceedings of an interdisciplinary ACACIA workshop held at the University of Cologne December 14-15, 2007: 189244. Colloquium Africanum 4. Heinrich-Barth-Institut, Cologne.
HERZOG, W. 2010: The Cave of Forgotten Dreams. Documentary film.
HEUSCH, L. de 2007[1987]: La inversión de la deuda (proposiciones acerca de las realezas sagradas africanas). In: Abensour, M. (comp.): El espíritu de las leyes salvajes. Pierre Clastres o una nueva antropología política: 95-120. Del Sol, Buenos Aires.
HILL, A. 1983: Hippopotamus butchery by homo erectus at Olduvai. Journal of Archaeological Science 10: 135-137. https://doi.org/10.1016/0305-4403(83)90047-X
HOFFMANN, M.A. 1989: Packaged funerals and the rise of Egypt. Archaeology 42: 48-51.
HOLMES, D. 1992: Chipped Stone-Working craftsmen, Hierakonpolis and the Rise of Civilization in Egypt. In: Adams, B. & Friedman, R.F. (eds.): The Followers of Horus. Studies dedicated to Michael Allen Hoffman 1944-1990: 37-44. ESA 2. Oxbow Monograph 20, Oxford.
HUYGE, D. 2009: Detecting magic in rock art: The case of the ancient Egyptian 'malignant ass'. In: Riemer, H.; Förster, F.; Herb, M. & Pöllath, N. (eds.): Desert animals in the eastern Sahara: Status, economic significance and cultural reflection in antiquity. Proceedings of an interdisciplinary ACACIA workshop held at the University of Cologne December 14-15, 2007: 293-307. Colloquium Africanum 4. Heinrich-Barth-Institut, Cologne.
JÈQUIER, G. 1940: Le monument funéraire de Pépi II. Tome III. Les aproches du temple. Cairo.
KINGDON, J. & HOFFMAN, M. (eds.) 2013: Mammals of Africa. Volume VI: Pigs, Hippopotamuses, Chevrotain, Giraffes, Deer and Bovids. Bloomsbury, London.
KÖHLER, Ch. 2002: History or Ideology?: New Reflections on the Narmer Palette and the Nature of Foreign Relations in Predynastic Egypt. In: Levy, E.T. & Van den Brink, E.C.M. (eds.): Egypt and the Levant: 499513. London.
LINSEELE, V.; VAN NEER, W. & HENDRICKX, S. 2007: Evidence for early cat taming in Egypt. Journal of Archaeological Science 34: 2081-2090. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2007.02.019
LINSEELE, V.; VAN NEER, W. & HENDRICKX, S. 2008: Early cat taming in Egypt: A correction. Journal of Archaeological Science 35: 2672-2673. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2008.04.009
LINSEELE, V.; VAN NEER, W. & FRIEDMAN, R. 2009: Special animals from a special place? The Fauna of HK29A at Predynastic Hierakonpolis. Journal of the American Research Center in Egypt 45: 105-136.
LYTHGOE, A.M. & DUNHAM, D. 1965: The Predynastic cemetery N7000. Naqa-ed-Der. Part IV. University of California Publications in Egyptian Archaeology, Berkeley.
MANLIUS, N. 2000: Biogéographie et écologie historique de l'hippopotame en Egypte. Belgian Journal of Zoology 130: 59-66.
MANLIUS, N. 2006: Des millénaires de grands mammifères terrestres et sauvages en Égypte. Ankh 14/15(2005/2006): 101-113.
MARKS, A.E. 1968: The Khormusan: an Upper Pleistocene industry in Sudanese Nubia. In: Wendorf, F. (ed.): The Prehistory of Nubia, vol. I: 315-391. Fort Burgwin Research Center and Southern Methodist University Press, Dallas.
MAYDANA, S. 2015: Of Hippopotami and Hawks. Some remarks on an Egyptianan Egyptian primeval rivalry. Cahiers Caribéens d'Egyptologie 19-20: 4960.
. MAYDANA, S. 2017: Implicancias simbólicas y sociopolíticas de las representaciones de la cacería del hipopótamo en Egipto predinástico. Bibliotheca Augustiniana Vol. VIII. https://doi.org/10.24215/22505121e021
MOND, R. & MYERS, O.H. 1937: Cemeteries of Armant I. Egypt Exploration Society, London.
MORROW, M. & MORROW, M. (eds.) 2002: Desert RATS. Rock Art Topographical Survey in Egypt's Eastern Desert. Bloomsbury Summer School. University College London, London.
MÜLLER, V. 2008: Nilpferdjagd und geköpfte Feinde zu zwei Ikonen des Feindvernichtungsrituals. In: Engel, E.M.; Müller, V. & Hartung, U. (eds.): Zeichen aus dem Sand. Streiflichter aus Ägyptens Geschichte zu Ehren von Günter Dreyer: 477-493. Menes 5. Otto-Harrassowitz, Wiesbaden.
MYERS, O.H 1933: Two Prehistoric Objects. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 19: 55. https://doi.org/10.1177/030751333301900110
PETRIE, W.M.F. 1901: Diospolis Parva. The Cemeteries of Abadiyeh and Hu 1898-9. Special extra publication of The Egypt Exploration Fund, London.
PETRIE, W.M.F. 1921: Corpus of Prehistoric Pottery and Palettes.
ERA y BSAE 32. Repr. Warminster, London.
PIERI, A. & FRIEDMAN, R. 2009: Two new tombs at HK6: The hippo hunters of Hierakonpolis. Nekhen News 21: 13-14.
PLUTARCH 1936: Moralia. with an English Translation by Frank Cole Babbitt. Harvard University Press. William Heinemann Ltd., Cambridge, MA.
ROUCH, J. 1950: La chasse à l'hippopotame. Documentary film.
SÄVE-SÖDERBERGH, T. 1953: On Egyptian representations of hippopotamus hunting as a religious motive. C.W.K. Gleerup, Lund.
SCHARFF, A. 1931: Die Altertümer der Vor-und Frühzeit Ägyptens I. Mitteilungen aus der Ägyptischen Sammlung, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin 5, Berlin.
TEETER, E. (ed.) 2011: Before the Pyramids. The Origins of Egyptian Civilization. Oriental Institute Museum Publications 33. The Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago, Chicago.
TE VELDE, H. 1967: Seth, God of Confusion. E.J. Brill, Leiden.
VAN NEER, W. & LINSEELE, V. 2009: Animal Hospital: Healed Animal Bones from HK6. Nekhen News 21: 11-12.
VAN NEER, W.; UDRESCU, M.; LINSEELE, V.; DE CUPERE, B. & FRIEDMAN, R. 2015: Traumatism in the Wild Animals kept and offered at Predynastic Hierakonpolis, Upper Egypt. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology: 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1002/oa.2440
WENGROW, D. 2006: The Archaeology of Early Egypt. Social Transformations in North-East Africa, c. 10.000 to 2.650 BC. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
WINKLER, H.A. 1938: Rock-Drawings of Southern Upper Egypt I. Egypt Exploration Society, London.
ZAJAC, A. 2008: Some remarks on the representation of so called boat procession from Wadi el-Barramiya (Eastern Desert of Egypt). Studies in Ancient Art and Civilization 12: 13-20.