BETWEEN EUPHORIA AND DESALINATION: THE GREATEST CONTRIBUTIONS OF BINET AND ITS IMPACT ON THE PSYCHOPEDAGOGICAL DIAGNOSIS OF THE 20TH CENTURY
Keywords:
Diferential Psycology, Individual Psycology, Intelligence Diagnosis, Psycological Laboratory, Intellectual level, Scale diagnosis, Binet-Simon test, Intelligence Quotient, L’Année Psycologique, Alfred Binet, Francis Galton, T.H Thorndike.Copyright (c) 2015 Tendencias Pedagógicas
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Abstract
The autor criticizes the frequent but disappointing references to Alfred Binet that can be found in our culture. He deeply analyzes as well in three levels, the significant influence Alfred Binet, has had into the modern Diferential Psicology, Education and Psycometric: -Binet and the change of objetives den Differential Psicology and the Psychodiagnostic of the intelligence at the beginning of the XX century. -Binet point of view about Scale Diagnosis and their contribution to Psychology and Psycometric. -The Mitification of the Binet-Simon Intelligence Scale and the condicioning factors of Differential Psycology and Psychodiagnosis during the first half of the XX century. García Yagüe supports his analysis with a wide bibliography, including several publications on the subject written by himself and with a large reproduction o Binet´s own texts that confirm the proposed thesis. These Binet texts have been translated from their original publications by Garcia Yagüe who would like to present them here with respect and as homage to Alfred Binet in the centenary of his death.Downloads
References
Avancini, G. (1969). La contribution d'Alfred Binet a l'élaboration d'une Pédagogie scientifique. Paris: Vrin.
Becker, K. (2003). A History of Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale: content and Psychometrics. Riverside Publishing: Noughton Mifflin Company (5ªedición de la Escala de Terman).
Andrieu, B. (2001). De la mesure de l'intelligence au développement mental: la mobilité épistémologique d' Alfred Binet. Enfance, 53, 101-107.
Binet, A., Henry, V. (1895). La psychologie individuelle. Année Psychologique, II, 405-65.
Binet, A. (1897). La Psychologie a l'école primaire. Année
Psychologique, 4, 1-14.
Binet, A. (1903). L'Analyse experimentales de l' intelligence. Paris: Scchleicher.
Binet, A., Simon, Th. (1905). Méthodes nouvelles pour le diagnostic du niveau intellectuel des anormaux, Année Psychologique, 11, 191-244. En este número hay 4 artículos todos ellos en colaboración con Simon
que ocupan casi 200 pgs.
Binet, A., Simon, Th., Vaney (1906). Recherches de Pédagogie Scientifique, Année Psychologique, 12, 233-74.
Binet, A. Simon, Th. (1911). Nouvelles recherché sur la mesure du niveau intellectual chez les enfants d'ecole. Année Psychologique, 17, pp. 145-201.
Bobertag, O. (1912). Quelques reflexions methodologiques à propos de l'echelle metrique de l'intelligence de Binet-Simon. Année Psychologique, 18, pp 271-87.
Burt, C. (1939). Binet's work on intelligence and its influence on Educational Psychology in England, en Jubilé de la Psychologie
scientifique française. Agen, Impr. Moderne, pp 167-84.
Chapuis, E. (1997). L'Année Psychologique dans la correspondence de Jean Larguier des Bancels, Année Psychologique, 97, 643-663.
Cunnigham, J. (1997) Alfred Binet and the quest for testing Higher Mental Functioning, in Wolfang Bringmann (edit.), A pictorial history of Psychology, Chicago: Quintessance Club
Delabarre, E. (1895). Les laboratoires de Psychologie en Amérique, Année Psychologique, I, 209-55.
Enzensberger, H.M. (2009). En el laberinto de la inteligencia. Guía para idiotas. Madrid: Anagrama (incluye su Himno a la estupidez).
Fagot, H. (2001). Alfred Binet et l'invention des tests d'intelligence. Sciences Humaines, 301.
Fancher, R.E. (1985). The intelligence men: Markers of I.Q. controversy. New York: Norton & Company.
Faver, D.P. (1992). Alfred Binet (1857-1911). Theorical and empirical contribution to the study of intelligence. Ph. Thesis Univ. Liverpool.
Forrest D.W. (1974). Francis Galton: The life and work of a Victorian Genius. London: Elck and New York, Taplinger.
Fraise, P., Ségui, J. (edit.) (1994). Les origines de la psychologie scientifique: centième anniversaire de L' Année Psychologique (1894- 1994). París: PUF.
García Yagüe, J. (1979). Binet y el condicionamiento de la Psicología Diferencial por el desarrollo de sus aplicaciones, en Memoria para el concurso Oposición a la plaza de Psicología Diferencial de la Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Legado García Yagüe, Museo
Pedagógico Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, pp. 178-251.
García Yagüe, J. (1987). El diagnóstico psicopedagógico moderno y sus grandes etapas hasta 1970, en Diagnóstico pedagógico y técnicas de orientación. Madrid: UNED, pp. 11-40.
García Yagüe, J. (2007). La larga, difícil y mal conocida aventura de la Orientación Escolar y Profesional tecnificada en España. Tendencias Pedagógicas, 12, 23-49.
Goodenouth, F.L (1950). Edward Lee Thorndike (1874-1949). The American Journal of Psychology, 63, 291-301.
Jung, C.G. (1909). L´Analyse des reves. L‘Année Psycologique,15,160-167.
Klein, A. (2008). Correspondance d´Alfred Binet: Jean Larguier des Bancels. Nancy: Presess University de Nancy.
Kohs, C. (1914). The Binet-Simon Measuring Scale for intelligence: an annoted bibliography. Journal Educational Psychology, pp. 215-24, 279-90 y 335-46.
Larguier des Bancels J. (1912). L´oeuvre d´Alfred Binet, L´Année Psycologique, 18, 15-32.
Nicolas, S.; Segui J et Ferrand, L. (2000). Les premières revues de Psycologique: la place de L´Année Psycologique. L´Année Psycologique, 100, 71-110.
Seagoe, M.V. (1975). Terman and the gifted, Los Altos-California: William Kaufmann.
Siegler, R. S. (1992). The other Alfred binet. Developmental Psychology, 2,179-90.
Simon, Th. (1912). Alfred Binet. L´Année Psycologique, 18, 1-14.
Sokal M. (1980). Science and James Mc Keen Cattel (1894-1945). Science, 209, 43-52.
Thorndike. E.L. (1904). An introduction to the theory of mental tests and social measurement. New York: Teacher College.
Thorndike. E.L. (1911). A scale for merit in Englishwritting by young people. Journal Educational Psychology, 7, 361-7.
Thorndike, R.L. (1918). The nature, purpose and general Methods of Measurement of Educational Products. Seventeens Teackbook of the Nacional Society for the study of Education, 16-22.
Vaney (1905). Nouvelles méthodes de mesure applicables au degré d´instruction des élèves. Année Psychologique, 12, 146-62.
Voyat, G. (1983). El auténtico mundo de Alfred Binet, Infancia y Aprendizaje, 22, 109-14.
Wolft, T.H. (1966). Alfredo Binet: Un periodo de crisis. Rev Psicologia General y Aplicada, 82/89, 295-315.
Wolft, T.H. (1973). Alfred Binet. Chicago: University Chicago Press.
Zazzo, R. (1946). Intelligence et Quotients d´ages. Paris: PUF.
Zazzo, R. (1993). Alfred Binet (1957-1911). Perspectives: revue trimestrelle d´education compare. Paris Unesco: 1-2,101-112.